/ 6 min read / Reed Smith Newsletters

IT & Data protection update – Germany 2/2026

1. OLG Brandenburg, judgment of 2 March 2026 – 1 U 1/24 (No GDPR damages for data breach caused by employee misconduct)

by Dr. Hannah von Wickede

Under Article 82 GDPR, the controller is liable for presumed fault but may exonerate itself by demonstrating that it exercised the required due care (Section 276(2) German Civil Code (BGB)) and implemented appropriate technical and organisational measures (Articles 24 and 32 GDPR). Unauthorised access by third parties alone does not prove that these measures were inadequate. For customer data requiring a low level of protection (name, address, phone number, email address), choosing the market leader as a service provider, contractually committed to GDPR compliance, was sufficient; the court considered a “dual-control principle” for support staff disproportionate. If a carefully selected employee misuses data for personal purposes (“employee misconduct”), neither the controller nor its processor is liable, because the employee then becomes a controller in their own right.

Conclusion: A data breach does not automatically result in liability. Those who carefully select service providers and employees and can demonstrate this have a good chance of exonerating themselves, at least in the case of data requiring a low level of protection.

2. OLG Munich, judgment of 23 April 2026 – 29 U 599/24 e (available in German only; no tying customer account activation to newsletter consent)

by Dr. Andreas Splittgerber

The Munich Higher Regional Court has confirmed what other courts and the German data protection authorities had already ruled: Linking registration with an online shop to consent to receive newsletters contravenes the prohibition on tying set out in Article 7(4) GDPR if the data subject has no genuine choice. The court examined in detail how the contractual requirement in Article 6(1)(b) GDPR should be interpreted and highlighted that placing an order as a guest could be a possible solution.

Conclusion: In terms of its outcome, the ruling is not new. However, the judgment is very detailed and highlights ways in which, and circumstances under which, linking newsletter subscriptions to online registration might be permissible. Every case is different. Businesses should make the most of this flexibility for their own circumstances.

3. Düsseldorf Administrative Court: Proof of consent to advertising emails

by Sven Schonhofen, LL.M.

The Düsseldorf Administrative Court (judgment of 27 July 2026, Case No. 29 K 9714/24) ruled that merely providing an email address, an IP address with a timestamp, and a double-opt-in IP address with a timestamp is not sufficient to prove consent to receive advertising emails. This data does not prove any relationship with the recipient of the advertising emails, nor does it indicate that consent was given at all. If the sender of the advertising emails cannot prove consent, it is deemed not to have been given or to be invalid.

Conclusion: The double opt-in procedure can still be used to provide evidence of consent to receive advertising emails. However, sufficient data must be stored to prove consent, particularly the wording of the consent declaration.

4. Legal notice email address must actually be reachable

by Joana Lawrence

A German higher regional court has recently ruled that listing an email address in the legal notice violates Section 5(1)(2) of the German Digital Services Act (DDG) if inquiries are answered only automatically with a message stating the address does not accept emails, along with a reference to other contact methods. While automated tools such as chatbots may be used to process incoming emails, if messages are rejected or users are immediately directed to other contact methods, the required “quick and straightforward communication” is lacking.

Conclusion: Companies should verify whether their legal notice email address actually accepts and processes incoming messages. “No-reply” addresses and auto-replies that merely refer users to other contact methods are insufficient and may result in cease-and-desist claims and warning letter fees.

5. CJEU, preliminary ruling of 9 July 2026 – Case C‑234/25 (Sky Austria – streaming service as a digital service)

by Dr. Carsten Dobler

The European Court of Justice has ruled (judgment of 9 July 2026, C‑234/25 – Sky Austria) that a streaming service constitutes a “digital service” rather than the provision of “digital content” if the service is dynamic, i.e. adapts to the behaviour of the individual user, for instance by analysing usage history or recommending specific content. In practice, this matters mainly in determining when the right of withdrawal expires: For digital content, it expires once a valid waiver has been obtained and performance has begun; for a digital service, only once the service has been fully provided.

Conclusion: Providers of streaming services should review their withdrawal right processes, including the instructions on withdrawal and the right of withdrawal waiver, and amend them where necessary.

6. Consent requirement for the collection of special categories of personal data by AI chatbots

by Annika Reimers, LL.M.

A German regional court has recently ruled that the processing of special categories of personal data by an AI chatbot requires the explicit consent of the user in the absence of another exception under Article 9(2) GDPR. Without consent, there is a violation of Article 5(1)(a) GDPR. This also applies if the user provides the sensitive information on their own initiative without being specifically asked. A mere disclaimer displayed when the AI chatbot is first used, which users only have to acknowledge, does not establish effective consent under data protection law.

Conclusion: Article 9(1) GDPR applies even when special categories of personal data are fed into an AI chatbot unsolicited by users (“unsolicited collection”).

Recommended reading on IT and data protection law in the EU and Germany

by Friederike Wilde-Detmering, M.A.

Related Insights