Tax measures to re-stimulate the economy
Alongside other policy levers, tax policy has a key role to play in re-stimulating the UK economy – targeted effectively it can support investment and consumer spending. Read Big economic policy choices for Johnson and Sunak – can history help them? for a previous article exploring these policy issues in more depth. So, what tax policy measures might we see from the Chancellor?
VAT
There are increasing calls for the Chancellor to follow the likes of Germany and cut VAT to boost consumer spending and help the economy bounce back from lockdown.
The rationale for a VAT cut is that it aims to leave consumers with more money in their pockets which they can then spend. It also seeks to encourage consumers to bring forward purchases of big ticket items (for example household goods).
There is of course a precedent for such a move – Alistair Darling temporarily cut the standard VAT rate from 17.5% to 15% in response to the 2008 financial crisis.
The jury is out on whether this would have the desired impact on day-to-day consumer spending that would justify the significant cost to the Treasury. Studies from the 2008 financial crisis suggest that this would not necessarily be the case.
Another option open to the Chancellor would be to make targeted VAT cuts as in Germany and Austria to help industries worst-hit by the COVID-19 pandemic such as tourism and hospitality.
If the Chancellor does decide to make VAT cuts, we can expect the changes to come into effect swiftly. Of course, a VAT cut now may pave the way for later increases in the headline VAT rate, as was the case in 2011.
National Insurance contributions
With a number of businesses already announcing job cuts, there are real concerns that UK unemployment levels could increase to those seen in the 1980s, particularly once the furlough scheme ends in October.
Employer National Insurance contributions (NICs) are the single largest labour cost for employers other than wages. Therefore, we might well see a reduction in the 13.8% employer NICs rate or an employer NICs ”holiday” for certain employees, which would make it cheaper for employers to retain staff.
Tax measures to plug the deficit
Income tax
According to a leaked Treasury paper in May, to raise fiscally significant amounts, the Government would need to increase taxes or change thresholds in one of the broad-based taxes (such as income tax, NICs, or VAT). HMRC calculations forecast that putting a penny on the basic rate of income tax alone would raise around £5 billion per year for the Government. A further £1 billion could be generated by a similar increase in the higher rate of tax.
While raising income tax rates would involve the Government breaking a key manifesto pledge, it would certainly be a quick and easy way for the Government to raise much needed revenue. Come the Autumn Budget, we might well see increases in income tax rates across all income tax bands, with higher earners subject to greater increases.
We know from prior recessions that tax cuts and tax benefits for lower and middle income families can prove the most effective in getting the economy moving again. With this in mind, the Chancellor could be creative and cut the basic rate of income tax or introduce a new lower rate of income tax for low income earners, with tax rises reserved for higher and additional tax rate taxpayers, thereby helping to “level up” the economy and balance the books.
As income tax is a marginal tax, another option the Government has is to lower the thresholds at which the higher and additional rates of income tax are paid. This may be considered more politically palatable as it would not directly break the Conservative 2019 manifesto pledge. This option would have to be balanced against the effect it might have on middle income earners, and so it would be important to decide where that middle-income boundary now lies.
National Insurance contributions
When Rishi Sunak announced the self-employment income support scheme, he fired a warning shot to the self-employed that they could be asked to contribute more in taxes in the future. With this in mind, we think it very likely that National Insurance contribution rates for self-employed individuals could be increased so that they more closely align with rates paid by employees.
Other changes to the NICs system that are being talked about include higher earners paying employee NICs at a flat rate of 12% on all of their earnings rather than the current two-tier system that taxes annual earnings between £9,501 and £50,000 at 12% and earnings above that at 2%. Effectively, that would be a 10% income tax rise for those affected. The Chancellor should be very careful before making such a change since that level of tax increase might risk an exodus of talent from London to rival financial centres. With the capital generating a massive 22% of UK GDP, such a move could be very costly to the Exchequer.
Capital gains tax
Capital gains tax (CGT) rates (currently at 20% for most assets) could be equalized with income tax rates (with a current top rate of 45%) as a revenue raising measure. Other possible reforms include raising the CGT rate to 28% (which currently only applies to certain assets) or narrowing the scope of the 10% entrepreneurs’ relief even further. While CGT brings in significantly less revenue than income tax, as a tax paid in practice by wealthier people, such a move could tie in neatly with Boris Johnson’s ‘leveling up’ agenda.
Wealth tax
The Labour Party has called on the Government to introduce a new ‘wealth tax’ whereby individuals in the UK would pay tax on the value of their assets. From an implementation perspective, introducing a wealth tax would be complicated. Questions like “would it be a one-off tax or an ongoing one?”, “what assets will be taken into account in calculating it?”, and “how do you value those assets?” would require careful consideration.
Introducing such a tax would, of course, not come naturally to a Conservative Government. With the end of the Brexit transition period looming, much like changing the employee NICs rate, the Government might be less inclined to introduce this type of tax as it seems to us that there is a significant risk that doing so could encourage wealth creators to leave the UK. As such, we suspect that Rishi Sunak is likely to focus his tax revenue raising activities elsewhere in the coming months.
Corporation tax
Corporation tax is the UK’s fourth largest tax, raising £58 billion in 2018/2019.
However, mindful of the need to protect businesses, we think the Government is unlikely to increase the main rate of corporation tax in the short term from its current 19% rate. Given that the UK’s corporation tax rate is at historically low levels, the Chancellor might feel he has the bandwidth to raise the corporation tax rate by a couple of percentage points in the future.
Another option for raising revenue could be to introduce a windfall tax on those companies that have benefited in the crisis. Recent polling by YOUGOV/NEON suggests that over half of people surveyed would be in favour of such a tax.
Comment
As the UK emerges from lockdown, Rishi Sunak’s main focus is likely to be on stimulus measures – and rightly so. He does, however, have the opportunity to make more far-reaching changes to the UK tax system. Based on the unprecedented steps he has taken so far to shore up the economy, we would not bet against the UK’s tax code receiving similar treatment.
Our Reed Smith Coronavirus team includes multidisciplinary lawyers from Asia, EME and the United States who stand ready to advise you on the issues above or others you may face related to COVID-19.
For more information on the legal and business implications of COVID-19, visit the Reed Smith Coronavirus (COVID-19) Resource Center or contact us at COVID-19@reedsmith.com.
Client Alert 2020-429