/ 1 min read

White-collar defense team unwinds guilty pleas and vindicates family business

After two years of hard-fought litigation, Reed Smith secured a rare non-prosecution agreement, undoing guilty pleas and dismissing every charge against our client under the Clean Water Act and the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA).

13

former prosecutors

Our team includes more than 13 former U.S. federal and state prosecutors and officials

A bet-the-company prosecution

In 2024, Bio-Edge, Inc., a small, family-run business, faced felony charges following an investigation by a U.S. attorney’s office and the Environmental Protection Agency into its waste handling and disposal practices. The charges alleged violations of the Clean Water Act and RCRA.

The case was particularly challenging for our white-collar defense team because two top executives and the company had already pleaded guilty.

Overcoming guilty pleas

Undoing a guilty plea after it has been entered in a federal criminal case is exceedingly rare. Our team needed to overturn felony convictions, shield the owners from personal criminal liability, and protect a company whose survival was on the line. The case also involved highly technical scientific and regulatory issues that had to be explained clearly and persuasively to the prosecutors, agents, and court. 

Our goal was clear: secure dismissal of all criminal charges, alleviate damage done to the owners, restore their reputations and financial position as much as possible, and allow them to move forward with their business.

Turning the case around

The trajectory of the case turned when our team discovered suppressed exculpatory evidence. Through pointed court filings, persuasive oral arguments, and aggressive negotiations, our team seized control of the narrative. We translated complex scientific issues into plain terms the court could easily follow, exposing serious flaws in the government’s case.

A complete victory

Our team achieved a non-prosecution agreement: a highly unusual result once felony charges have been filed and guilty pleas entered. The government dismissed every criminal charge against Bio-Edge and its owners, including those brought under the Clean Water Act and RCRA, and all guilty pleas were withdrawn.

After two years of hard-fought litigation, the threat to Bio-Edge’s business is gone, and its owners can move forward with their names cleared.

The content of this publication is for informational purposes and is not intended to cover all developments in the areas discussed. The author, publisher, and distributor are not providing legal advice. You should not act or refrain from acting based on the content without seeking appropriate legal counsel from a properly licensed attorney in your jurisdiction. Portions of the publication may be considered Attorney Advertising under the applicable rules of certain states.

“We are pleased to have this matter satisfactorily resolved. We are proud of our over 30-year record of good standing with all local, state, and federal regulatory bodies. Robert [Sulc, senior chemist at Bio-Edge], I, and the company as a whole look forward to continuing to provide the highest level of service to our customers. We are grateful to the Reed Smith legal team for helping us achieve this extraordinary result.”

Filip Sulc, PhD, President and CEO of Bio-Edge

Related Insights