Margaret C. McDonald

she/her/hers

Partner

Margaret is a partner in the Insurance Recovery Group, where she advises clients on a variety of insurance issues. She is an experienced litigator and has worked on a wide range of coverage disputes. Margaret has actively participated in all stages of litigation, from pre-litigation ADR to cross-examinations at trial. Her insurance experience includes representing clients in disputes involving D&O, EPL, CGL, property, and mortgage insurance, among others. Margaret also maintains an active pro bono practice and has successfully represented clients in special immigrant juvenile status and asylum proceedings.

Margaret’s prior experience includes defending large corporations, investor-owned public utilities, and property owners during all stages of litigation, in matters ranging from environmental clean-up and wildfire litigation to catastrophic losses and international real property disputes.

During law school, Margaret was an extern for the Hon. Maureen Tighe in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Central District of California; a Senior Editor of the Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics, & Public Policy; and a student at the Notre Dame London Law Centre. She graduated magna cum laude from Notre Dame, where she was on the Dean’s List from 2013 to 2015 and received Dean’s Awards in Negotiations, Jurisprudence, and International Trade.

Prior to law school, Margaret graduated cum laude from the University of San Francisco, with a B.A. in History. While an undergraduate, she spent a year at the University of Oxford, where she studied medieval British history. In her spare time, Margaret enjoys reading, traveling, and cooking.

Experience

Representative matters

Successfully defended hospitality entity against multiple motions to dismiss in COVID-19 litigation over nine-figure insurance claim
Represented mortgage servicers in a number of disputes with mortgage insurers over claims stemming from the Great Recession
Represented a variety of entities, both public and private, in environmental coverage disputes with losses ranging up to the eight figures and often involving historic insurance programs

Recognitions

  • Recognized by Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch® in America (Commercial Litigation; Insurance Law), 2023–2027

  • Winner of 2025 Business Insurance Break Out Award

Credentials

Education

  • Notre Dame Law School, 2015, J.D., magna cum laude
  • University of San Francisco, 2010, B.A., cum laude

Professional admissions & qualifications

  • California

Court admissions

  • U.S. District Court - Central District of California
  • U.S. District Court - Eastern District of California

News

Media mentions