/ 8 min read / Reed Smith Newsletters

Ten top tips for navigating antitrust litigation

Antitrust litigation continues to intensify across jurisdictions, driven by aggressive government enforcement, growing private damages actions, and new challenges posed by digital markets and evolving supply chains. The specific substantive law and factual defenses will, of course, be unique to each antitrust case (and these are essential to identify early and develop throughout the litigation). But there are also fundamental litigation management practices and processes that are common across borders and different substantive defenses, and that apply whether the client is facing a follow-on claim triggered by a regulatory investigation or a standalone private action. This edition sets out ten top litigation management tips drawn from current practice in major jurisdictions to help businesses protect their interests in this high-stakes arena.

1. Anticipate parallel proceedings and coordinate your response

Antitrust disputes rarely exist in isolation. A government investigation in one jurisdiction will frequently prompt parallel antitrust claims, including private damages claims, sometimes in multiple countries simultaneously. In some jurisdictions, the findings of a competition authority can serve as binding or prima facie evidence of unlawful conduct in subsequent private litigation. News of an investigation can prompt private plaintiffs to bring claims while the investigation is still ongoing. Alternatively, and more commonly, plaintiffs will wait until the investigation has concluded so that they can rely on its findings to avoid the cost and difficulty of proving liability without an infringement decision. Businesses should plan from the outset for the possibility that an enforcement matter in one market will generate litigation exposure in several others, and should develop a coordinated, cross-border defense strategy that accounts for the interplay between public and private proceedings.

2. Preserve evidence and protect privilege and leniency materials

Businesses should put document preservation measures in place as soon as litigation is reasonably anticipated, including preserving relevant electronic communications and suspending routine deletion practices, to avoid the potentially serious consequences of failing to preserve evidence.

“Legal professional privilege” is a critical shield in antitrust litigation, protecting confidential communications between lawyers and clients made for the purpose of giving or receiving legal advice. In many jurisdictions, “litigation privilege” (or work-product protection) also covers confidential communications with third parties, such as economists and other experts, made for the purpose (in some jurisdictions, the dominant purpose) of actual or reasonably contemplated litigation. Many jurisdictions protect in-house legal advice, but not all do – for example, communications with in-house counsel are not privileged in European Commission investigations. Businesses must therefore involve external counsel where sensitive advice is required. Businesses should be vigilant about maintaining privilege from the earliest stages of any internal investigation or compliance review, as any waiver – even an inadvertent one – can have serious consequences. Privilege can be lost, for example, by circulating advice widely within the business, sharing it with third parties without appropriate protections, or referring to its substance in non-privileged documents. Where multiple companies are defendants or targets of the same investigation, businesses should also implement joint defense agreements that support communications among counsel for the defendants or targets without endangering the confidentiality of those communications or of information exchanged in the defense context.

Equally, leniency materials and settlement submissions attract special protections in many jurisdictions. In some jurisdictions, such as the EU and the UK, courts cannot order disclosure of cartel leniency statements or settlement submissions that have not been withdrawn. However, in the United States, for example, a leniency recipient may need to cooperate with private plaintiffs in follow-on litigation to obtain benefits such as reduced damages exposure. The interaction between leniency cooperation obligations and privilege protections demands careful management.

3. Understand standing and who can sue you

Not every party that claims to have been affected by anti-competitive conduct has the right to bring a claim for damages. Across jurisdictions, the law imposes important requirements around standing – that is, whether a particular plaintiff is legally allowed to seek compensation. Some systems distinguish between direct and indirect purchasers, with varying rules about which parties at different levels of the supply chain may bring suit. In the United States, for example, indirect purchaser claims are barred under federal law but may be permitted under state or regional laws, creating a patchwork of exposure. Understanding who has standing – and who does not – is essential to framing an effective defense.

4. Challenge claims early and rigorously

Private antitrust actions are frequently resolved before trial, often through early procedural challenges. Defendants should use every available procedural mechanism to test the merits of a claim as early as possible. In some jurisdictions, courts apply a plausibility standard at the pleading stage, requiring plaintiffs to set out specific facts supporting their claim rather than relying on mere speculation. Courts take these threshold challenges seriously, recognizing that the burdens of antitrust discovery and disclosure can otherwise pressure defendants into settling weak claims. Whether the procedural tool is a motion to dismiss, a strike-out application, or a summary judgment request, an early and robust challenge can be the most cost-effective defense available.

5. Take control of the disclosure and discovery process

The exchange of discovery materials is one of the most burdensome and consequential phases of antitrust litigation. In some jurisdictions, such as the United States, discovery is broad, covering any non-privileged matter that is relevant to a party’s claim or defense and proportional to the needs of the case, whether or not it would be admissible at trial. This can be particularly costly in antitrust cases, where class actions and complex economic issues multiply the volume of material at stake. In other systems, disclosure is more targeted, with courts ordering specific categories of documents and encouraging pre-action exchanges to promote early resolution. Defendants should engage proactively with the disclosure process: identify privileged materials early, resist disproportionate document and data requests, and use the rules of proportionality to manage scope and cost. Businesses should also keep a clear record of what they have produced to each authority during any investigation, as plaintiffs are likely to seek those materials in later disclosure, and the defense should remain consistent with them.

6. Invest in expert economic evidence

Economic expert analysis is the engine of modern antitrust litigation. In virtually every jurisdiction, economic experts play a central role in establishing or defeating key elements of a claim, including market definition, market power, dominance, the existence and extent of an overcharge, class certification, and the quantification of damages. Courts scrutinize expert methodology closely and may exclude testimony that is not based on reliable principles or sufficiently grounded in the facts of the case. In some jurisdictions, courts may appoint their own expert or direct that expert evidence be given concurrently in a process known as “hot-tubbing.” The quality of expert evidence can determine the outcome of a case, particularly at the damages stage, and businesses should invest in experienced, credible experts from the outset. Businesses should also consider investing in non-testifying economic consultants who work with counsel to develop substantive and factual defenses, and whose work would be protected from discovery by the work product doctrine or similar protections.

7. Prepare for the complexities of damages assessment

Damages in antitrust cases are compensatory in nature in most jurisdictions, aiming to place the claimant in the position it would have been in absent the unlawful conduct. However, assessing loss in practice is rarely straightforward. Some jurisdictions provide for enhanced damages, such as treble damages in the United States, which significantly multiply the financial exposure. Others, such as the EU, have adopted rebuttable presumptions that cartels cause harm, shifting part of the evidentiary burden onto defendants. Plaintiffs must prove that damages were caused by the unlawful conduct and not by independent factors – a principle known as disaggregation – and defendants should be prepared to challenge the causal link at every stage. Courts have also recognized categories of loss beyond simple overcharge, including lost profits, loss of opportunity, and even moral or reputational damage. A thorough understanding of the available heads of damage and of the defenses to each is essential.

8. Deploy the pass-on defense strategically

The pass-on defense is a key tool for defendants in antitrust damages claims, though its availability varies significantly across jurisdictions. In some jurisdictions, including the UK and EU Member States, defendants may seek to reduce their damages exposure by showing that a claimant passed some or all of an alleged overcharge on to its own customers, although the defendant bears the burden of proving pass-on. By contrast, in U.S. federal antitrust damages actions, defendants generally cannot invoke the pass-on defense against direct purchasers, subject to limited exceptions, and indirect purchasers generally cannot recover damages under federal law (see tip 3). Understanding these distinctions is essential to evaluating potential damages exposure and developing an effective defense strategy. Defendants should also be aware that even where pass-on is established, claimants may seek to recover for consequential losses – such as reduced sales volume – that flowed from the price increase they passed on to their customers. 

9. Be alert to joint and several liability and settlement dynamics

In many jurisdictions, defendants in a cartel action are jointly and severally liable for the full extent of the harm caused by the unlawful conduct. This means that a single defendant may be required to pay the entire damages award, not just its proportionate share, particularly where co-conspirators have settled for a discounted amount. The absence of a right to seek contribution from co-conspirators in some jurisdictions intensifies this exposure. This dynamic creates significant pressure to settle early, as non-settling defendants face the risk of bearing a disproportionate share of the overall liability. Businesses should carefully evaluate settlement timing, coordinate with co-defendants where possible, and consider different cost regimes, contribution, or apportionment mechanisms available under applicable law.

10. Monitor the evolving landscape, from digital markets to collective actions

The antitrust litigation environment is changing rapidly. Jurisdictions around the world are expanding the scope of private enforcement, introducing new collective or class action mechanisms, and grappling with novel theories of harm arising from digital markets, algorithmic pricing, and big tech platforms. In some markets, legislators are contemplating restrictions on the use of algorithms to coordinate pricing among competitors, while enforcement agencies are actively challenging such practices. At the same time, the growth in third-party litigation funding is reshaping the economics of antitrust claims, enabling larger and more ambitious cases – although the regulatory framework for funding arrangements is itself in flux. Governments are also reviewing whether alternative dispute resolution and voluntary redress schemes should play a greater role in delivering compensation to consumers. Businesses should stay abreast of these developments and ensure their compliance programs and litigation preparedness reflect the current – and emerging – enforcement priorities in every market where they operate.

Conclusion

Antitrust litigation demands a global perspective. While the procedural rules and substantive standards differ from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, the core principles remain consistent: anticipate parallel proceedings, preserve evidence and protect privilege, understand who can sue, challenge claims early, control the disclosure process, invest in expert analysis, prepare for damages and pass-on arguments, manage settlement dynamics, and stay ahead of a rapidly evolving enforcement landscape. Businesses that adopt a proactive, coordinated, and well-informed approach to antitrust litigation will be best positioned to protect their interests across borders.

Related Insights