/ 5 min read

Fifth Circuit Rejects CFIUS Preemption Challenge to Texas Critical Infrastructure Law as Texas AG Re-Proposes SB 17 Rules

On October 16, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit rejected a Chinese-owned energy developer’s argument that federal law governing the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) displaces the Texas Lone Star Infrastructure Protection Act (LSIPA). One week earlier, on October 9, the Texas Office of the Attorney General (OAG) published a second set of proposed rules implementing Senate Bill 17 (SB 17), the state’s 2025 restrictions on real property acquisitions by certain foreign persons and entities. Together, these developments underscore the need to assess Texas foreign-ownership restrictions alongside federal review.

Key takeaways

  • LSIPA restricts critical infrastructure deals, and CFIUS clearance does not resolve it. LSIPA bars Texas businesses and government entities from giving companies tied to China, Iran, North Korea, Russia, or a designated country access to or control of critical infrastructure, such as the grid. The CFIUS safe harbor protects a transaction only from further CFIUS action; the plaintiff’s prior CFIUS mitigation agreement did not prevent ERCOT from denying its grid interconnection under LSIPA.
  • Preemption challenges face a steep climb in the Fifth Circuit. The court applied a heightened presumption against preemption for utility regulation and noted that, in close cases, “the tie goes to the state.”
  • SB 17 restricts foreign real property acquisitions, including leases and changes of control. Since September 1, 2025, SB 17 has barred certain foreign individuals, governments, and foreign-controlled companies from acquiring interests in Texas real property, with criminal and civil penalties. Under the proposed rules, successive short-term arrangements that, in substance, create a leasehold of one year or longer are covered, as is obtaining control of an entity that holds Texas real property.
  • Deal professionals would become reporters. Under SB 17’s proposed rules, lenders, title insurers, property insurers, appraisers, and real estate licensees would be required to report acquisitions they know or should have known, after reasonable due diligence, violate SB 17.

The Fifth Circuit decision

LSIPA bars Texas governmental entities and businesses from entering into agreements relating to critical infrastructure, such as the electric grid managed by the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT), with a company they know is majority owned or controlled by citizens or entities of China, Iran, North Korea, Russia, or a governor-designated country, or is headquartered in one of them, if the agreement would grant the company “direct or remote access to or control of critical infrastructure in this state” (other than access allowed for product warranty and support). Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 117.002; Tex. Gov’t Code § 2275.0102. The plaintiff, a Texas subsidiary of a China-headquartered group, challenged ERCOT’s 2022 cancellation of its interconnection request for a solar project. Its affiliates had previously entered into a CFIUS mitigation agreement with the Department of Defense.

The panel found no preemption of either kind. There was no conflict because CFIUS covers a narrow set of transactions, while LSIPA governs infrastructure agreements, a core state police power, and adds an “upward variance” in security. There was no field preemption because Congress gave no sign of excluding the states from a limited, largely voluntary federal regime.

The re-proposed SB 17 rules

SB 17 added Subchapter H (§§ 5.251–5.259) to Chapter 5 of the Texas Property Code. It prohibits certain foreign individuals, governmental entities, and foreign-owned or foreign-controlled companies from purchasing or otherwise acquiring an interest in Texas real property, creates a criminal offense and a civil penalty, and authorizes the OAG to investigate and bring enforcement actions. The OAG’s March 2026 proposal lapsed without adoption. The new proposal, 1 Tex. Admin. Code ch. 67 (§§ 67.1–67.12), appears in the October 9, 2026 Texas Register. Litigation over SB 17 continues, and whether federal CFIUS law preempts SB 17 remains unsettled.

Carried forward from March:

  • Leaseholds of less than one year remain outside the definition, but a series of licenses, leases, or other arrangements that in substance create a leasehold of one year or longer is covered.
  • “Purchase or otherwise acquire” includes any transaction, including a redemption, by which a person obtains control of an entity that owns Texas real property, regardless of when the entity acquired it.
  • “Control” is defined broadly. General partners, managing members, holders of 10% or more of voting interests, executive officers, and anyone with a present or future right to acquire or dispose of the entity’s Texas property are deemed to have control.
  • A facilitating entity that knows, or should have known after reasonable due diligence, of a violation must file a complaint and may be referred to its licensing authority if it does not.
  • Complaints and investigative records would be confidential but could be shared with federal agencies.

New in October:

  • A diligence safe harbor protects qualifying facilitating entities from being deemed to have known or should have known of a violation if they conduct qualifying know-your-customer diligence and discover no violation.
  • A voluntary mechanism allows anyone to report property owned by covered persons that was acquired before September 1, 2025. A report is not a complaint and is not a finding of a violation.
  • The OAG may plan a public property search portal modeled on other public registries.

How the regimes fit together

Foreign investors in Texas face overlapping federal and state requirements. CFIUS conducts federal, transaction-specific review of covered transactions. LSIPA restricts agreements for access to critical infrastructure and is applied at the point of contracting; since 2023, ERCOT may not register or interconnect an entity unless it attests to LSIPA compliance. SB 17 restricts acquisitions of real property interests, including qualifying leases and entity-level control. A single project may implicate all three and clearing one does not clear the others. Depending on the business and transaction, additional requirements may apply, including FCC foreign ownership and transfer-of-control approvals, export controls, sanctions, and facility security requirements.

Recommended steps

Companies and investors with Texas exposure should add a Texas-specific review, covering both LSIPA and SB 17, to their transaction diligence. This review should sit alongside any CFIUS analysis. It should trace indirect ownership and governance rights against the proposed control tests, including the 10% voting threshold. For leasing, parties should review renewal, extension, and holdover provisions and successive short-term arrangements to assess whether they, in substance, create a leasehold of one year or longer. Any restructuring, redemption, or other change of control involving an entity that holds Texas property should be vetted before closing, because it can be treated as a new acquisition even for property held before September 1, 2025.

Parties should also expect closer ownership questions from lenders, title companies, and insurers, which would gain a diligence safe harbor under the proposed rules. We will continue to monitor the litigation and rulemaking.

For assistance, please contact any of the authors or the Reed Smith lawyer with whom you regularly work. This alert is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.